A Positive Approach
For most of us, the word “discipline” conjures up thoughts of reactive and controlling measures for dealing with student misbehavior. However, the model of discipline proposed in The Win-Win Classroom is an ongoing, proactive set of behaviors used to create a cooperative environment that minimizes the likelihood of negative, disruptive behavior. This positive discipline process can occur at any level or in any group—a classroom, department, building, or district.
Consider yourself fortunate if you are working with teachers who are already committed to a win-win discipline approach. They will make your job much easier. These are teachers who assume responsibility for handling misbehaviors that occur in their classrooms. They will see you as a resource, not a rescuer, and will be far less likely to request that you solve their discipline problems for them. In contrast, teachers who use typical win-lose strategies frequently find those techniques frustrating and ineffective for managing conflicts with students, parents, or other teachers, and may frequently ask that you intervene.
The attitudes of win-win teachers are generally more positive than their authoritarian counterparts; they are also able to provide an atmosphere that encourages growth and learning without the stress and external control typical in a win-lose classroom. By focusing on the connections between choices and outcomes, these teachers help students take responsibility for their actions and behaviors. As a result, their students are more likely to exhibit initiative, independence, self-management and an awareness of others’ needs than students in a win-lose classroom, who often do only what is required to get by or stay safe. Win-win teachers are also clear about their limits and boundaries, and secure enough to encourage empowerment among their students.
Yet, a win-win approach to discipline can be quite a challenge for any teacher unfamiliar with win-win management models. To generate their commitment, these teachers first need to learn how this approach can pay off for them. As often occurs in the life of an administrator, your job will involve selling these ideas to them, giving them good enough reasons to want to change what, in many instances, will be deeply ingrained habits and ideas.
If necessary, start with staff members who are most open to change, perhaps those who have already indicated a commitment to win-win objectives, if not the actual skill to reach them. Allow their successes to be the invitation and inspiration for others. These teachers will need information about effective adult behaviors for achieving a variety of interactive goals. Your support will encourage them to take risks and try new approaches and will help build confidence in developing new techniques. Keep in mind that implementing successful changes in the classroom takes time and effort. A win-win focus involves rethinking, relearning and retraining, and could take some teachers a number of years to fully implement.
Beware of the difficulties inherent in attempting to require across-the-board attitude changes or even implement any particular discipline program school- or district-wide. Be especially wary of programs that offer quick fixes or simple formulas for managing or reacting to children’s behavior, regardless of the amount of pressure you feel from your community or staff.*
Relationship building—the key to minimizing discipline problems—is a process. Since so many of the changes necessary in making a transition from industrial-age beliefs and behaviors to those of an information-age model occur at a very personal level—and on a very individual basis—you probably won’t have much success attempting to mandate the change or trying to establish a win-win approach as a uniform discipline code. (Adults aren’t much different from kids when it comes to being told what to do, especially if such mandates include directives about how to feel or what to tolerate!) Work with your core group and anyone who cares to join in and focus your energies on creating a school climate in which win-win interactions are likely to emerge.
The strategies described in this book also apply well to adult relationships. This may translate to letting go, or to sharing some of your authority to involve teachers in decisions you may have previously made alone. Empowered teachers, those who feel they have input in decisions that affect them, have a greater stake in—and are more likely to commit enthusiastically to—the success and welfare of the organization.
As an administrator, begin to think of new ways to motivate, empower, value, inspire, and build commitment with your staff, perhaps by:
• giving them opportunities to suggest topics and resources for inservice and staff development programs
• presenting options for scheduling, room assignment or grade level
• trying to accommodate staff members’ needs for input and choice when making administrative decisions that concern them
• providing the most direct channels possible for access to supplies, resource personnel and yourself
• modeling the beliefs, behaviors, language patterns and attitudes you would like your teachers to adopt
• offering acceptance, feedback and support while encouraging teachers to solve their problems themselves
• resisting the habit to get in the middle of—and taking responsibility for—squabbles between kids and teachers, even if that’s always been your job
• refusing to punish students for infractions you did not witness
• helping teachers resolve conflicts with other staff members or parents without assuming responsibility for the solution of the problems
• encouraging the development or creation of a reward-oriented school environment; helping teacher find ways to increase the number of positive options they can offer to students
• providing resources or support necessary to help teachers develop success-oriented instruction and routines (make success possible for students at a variety of ability levels)
• being visible in non-conflict arenas; visiting every classroom, as often as possible, to offer feedback or just help out finding something positive to say about every member of your staff
• making time to regularly acknowledge the contributions your staff members make (including casual, informal verbal or written messages of recognition and appreciation)
• encouraging (not requiring) your staff to do the same for one another
• using motivators to show appreciation, recognize special achievements, or just break up routines
• identifying and changing negative, reactive school policies
• maintaining regular and positive communication with the community
• taking care of yourself; learning to let go, delegate, set and maintain boundaries
As you model cooperative interactions with students, parents, and staff, you will set the tone for the entire school. The payoffs for you and the other adults in your building are considerable. But in terms of learning, behavior, and self-concept, the real winners are the students.
© 1985, 2008, 2012, 2022, Dr. Jane Bluestein.
Excerpted and adapted from The Win-Win Classroom, by Dr. Jane Bluestein, © 2008, Corwin Publishing, Thousand Oaks, CA. This material originally appeared on this site under the title “Creating a 21st Century Discipline School: Implications for Administrators.”
See other handouts and excerpts from The Win-Win Classroom:
Improving Student Behavior through Positive School Climate
Building Your Classroom Community
Guidelines for Offering Choices to Students
Guidelines for Reinforcing Positive Student Behavior
Dealing Successfully with your Students’ Parents
Getting Away with Success
Motivating Cooperative Student Behavior
Handling Negative Student Behavior
More information about The Win-Win Classroom! This book will be a helpful gift for a beginning teacher or someone just having a tough year. It has also been used by a number of administrators to help break through the resistance of teachers who typically employ negative, hurtful, and ineffective strategies with their kids (and colleagues).
Please support this site: This website is an ongoing labor of love, with a fair number of expenses involved. Your support will help offset the cost of continual training, technical assistance, and translators, allowing me to continue to maintain the site, add helpful and inspiring new content and links, and keep the site ad-free. Donate here…